Should You Inform a Police Officer About Carrying Concealed During a Stop Without Being Asked?

When a police officer stops your vehicle, the question arises whether you should inform them about carrying a concealed weapon if you are not specifically asked. This situation depends on a balance of the officer's intentions and your personal safety.

Context Matters: Keeping It Business or Going on a Fishing Expedition?

Not all stops are the same. If the officer primarily intends to write a ticket for minor violations, it is often best to keep quiet. However, if the officer seems detail-oriented and is interested in pulling you over for a prolonged search or investigation (a fishing expedition), you may consider making a concise statement about your gun.

Some officers may respect your silence and leave without further issues. Others might decide to conduct a more thorough search, especially if they believe you are concealing something without disclosure. It's important to stay calm and cooperative, regardless of the officer's demeanor.

Understanding Potential Uncleared Perceptions and Legal Actions

Many people falsely believe that telling an officer about carrying a concealed weapon gives them the authority to detain or search you further. This is a common misconception. Unless you have violated another law, the officer typically does not have legal grounds to detain you further based solely on your disclosure. However, revealing this information can still cause tension and may result in an unnecessary search.

Additionally, the officer can check your information through any of the standard procedures, such as running your license plate or checking your driver’s license and registration. If you are carrying a firearm, they can also record your serial number or verify your permit. The key is to be prepared and calm when these situations arise.

Best Practices for Preparing for a Traffic Stop

To avoid any unexpected inconveniences or misunderstandings, it is advisable to have your driver's license, registration, and proof of insurance ready before the officer even approaches your window. If you happen to be carrying a firearm, additionally have your concealed carry permit in your possession.

When the officer reaches your window, hand over the required documents, and if you are carrying, inform them where your firearm is stored. In situations where the officer pulls you over for traffic violations, whether for speeding or having a broken tail light, a straightforward and calm explanation can often resolve the situation more smoothly.

For example, in two instances I have been stopped for traffic violations, one for speeding and another for a broken brake light. In both cases, I disclosed that I was carrying a concealed weapon, and the officer ran my information. In the first, I received a ticket, while in the second, I received a verbal warning.

Had I not disclosed my situation, the outcome might have been the same. However, transparency avoids any potential misunderstandings that could arise if you move unexpectedly or your firearm becomes visible. It is a matter of trust and cooperation, minimizing the risk of escalation.

Remember, it is a smart practice to always be prepared and cooperative, but only disclose the information if it is necessary to clarify any misunderstandings or ensure your safety. This approach aligns with best practices in dealing with police during traffic stops.