The Complicated Past and Modern Friendship: A Canadian Perspective on the American Revolution

Many Canadians might find it surprising to learn that the American Revolution, while a critical moment in history, is rarely a source of extended controversy or hatred in our society. As a fellow Canadian, I feel it’s necessary to shed some light on why this is the case and what the true state of affairs is between our nations.

Historical Perspective and Modern Friendship

From Canada’s perspective, the American War of Independence is an episode from the distant past that no longer influences our relationship today. We view it as a historical event that occurred 240 years ago and has long been settled.
We do not harbour any lasting resentment or hatred towards the United States over this historical event. The signing of the Treaty of Ghent in 1814, which ended the conflict, has long since brought the issue to a close. While both nations share a common colonial past, our paths diverged long ago.

Understanding the Divide Between Canada and the United States

For many Canadians, the American Revolution is a distant memory, beyond the realm of current concerns or personal interests. The pride that Americans have for their war of independence is recognized and respected, but it does not engage us in the same way. We have our own history, one that is just as significant and complex.
The war of independence was a pivotal moment for the United States, and a source of national pride. But in Canada, our history is different, one that led us down another path and to form our own distinct identity.

Modern Relations and Shared Ideals

Both nations have moved on from the tensions of the past and have established a strong relationship that is not defined by historical grievances. In fact, Canada and the United States are more than just friends; they are the best of friends. We share the same values of democracy, freedom, and human rights, and these shared ideals continue to bind us together today.
We focus on the present and the future, not on unresolved historical conflicts. This shared future is one where we can continue to flourish and prosper, supported by the strong bonds that exist between our two nations.

Historical Truth and Interpretation

As an amateur historian, I have a unique perspective on the events of the American Revolution. The version often portrayed in popular media, such as films and books, simplifies and often distorts the truth of what actually happened. The 'Disneyland version' of history simplifies complex events and can lead to a misunderstanding of the true narrative.

For instance, the 'Patriot' film portrayed the revolution in a highly romanticized and often exaggerated manner, leading many to believe certain events never happened. Historians, like Hugh Bicheno, have debunked many of these myths, revealing the complexity and nuance of the conflict.

One example is the myth of the 'Lexington and Concord' story, which has been found to be largely false. The American Loyalists, American Aboriginal peoples, the 30,000 freed slaves by the British, the French Army and Navy at Yorktown, and the Spanish and Dutch presence were all fabrications of Hollywood. The portrayal of George III as a tyrant and the 'Boston Massacre' as a piece of fiction are further examples of historical inaccuracies.

It is crucial to understand that these historical narratives are not merely academic debates but have real-world implications. They shape our understanding of the past and influence our present and future actions.

In conclusion, as a Canadian, while the American Revolution is a significant and complex part of history, it does not define our relationship with the United States. We cherish and respect the achievements of the American Revolution and recognize the shared values that unite our two nations. Let us continue to foster a relationship based on mutual respect and understanding, and let us uphold the principles of democracy and freedom for which both countries stand.

References

Hugh Bicheno. Rebel Redcoats: Inside the American Revolution. Crown Publishers, 2005.