Why the Fear of CBI in India Persists

In recent years, the Criminal Investigation Bureau (CBI) in India has faced increasing scrutiny and criticism, not for its effectiveness in investigating crimes but for its perceived role as a political tool. The CBI, once an independent body meant to uphold the law, is now viewed with suspicion by many. This article explores the reasons behind this growing fear and the broader implications for law enforcement in the country.

The CBI as a Political Tool

One of the primary concerns regarding the CBI is its frequent use as a political instrument in India. Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his administration have been accused of using the CBI to target political rivals and individuals who expose wrongdoing. For instance, when high-profile criminals such as Vijay Mallya and other Gujrati business magnates fled the country, the CBI appeared to be napping. This inaction raises questions about the bureau's impartiality and effectiveness.

Law Enforcement Tools for Targeted Terrorization

The Central Bureau of Investigation's (CBI) Enforcement Directorate (ED) and Income Tax (IT) department have been described as pets that follow the master's orders to terrorize and apprehend selective people, particularly those who ask questions. This has led to widespread fear among citizens, especially those who suspect that evidence against them might exist or be fabricated.

The Fear is Widespread, Not Just among the Guilty

It is important to recognize that the fear of law enforcement agencies is not limited to just those who are guilty. Even innocent individuals are apprehensive due to the arbitrary nature of arrests and the lack of accountability for unjust actions. The case of Mujtoba Ali Maqbool is a stark example. Despite spending 17 months in prison without any concrete evidence, he was eventually released. This incident highlights the abuse of power by law enforcement agencies in India.

The Legacy of Guilt and Suspicion

Political figures often become tainted over time, and the fear of investigation is a widespread sentiment among various politicians. However, it is not just about guilt; it is also about the fear of being silenced or punished for asking questions. A guilty conscience is always suspicious, leading to a general fear of investigation agencies, especially those that hold evidence against them.

Citizens Fear and Its Impact on the System

The fear of law enforcement in India is not just a personal issue but a reflection of a deeply flawed system. The case of the Talwars, where the assumption of guilt was based on the daughter not crying, further underscores the issue. Such instances reveal a broader problem of citizens fearing their cops, which is a great shame for the country. A system that leaves innocent citizens fearful of its own law enforcement is indeed a warning sign of a fundamentally flawed and untrustworthy system.

Conclusion

The fear of CBI and other law enforcement agencies is a complex societal issue in India. It stems from a combination of political interference, arbitrary arrests, and the arbitrary nature of evidence. This fear is not just about the guilty but extends to the innocent. Addressing these issues is crucial for rebuilding public trust in the justice system and ensuring that law enforcement agencies fulfill their role as protectors of the people rather than enforcers of political whims.