The Question of Jon Snow's Vows

In the A Song of Ice and Fire series by George R.R. Martin, the Night's Watch and its vows have often been central to the story. One of the most intriguing questions revolves around Jon Snow and his position within the Night's Watch. If Ned Stark came to the Wall and declared Jon as heir to the Iron Throne, would he be released from his vows? The answer to this question is not straightforward and involves multiple layers of interpretation and potential outcomes.

The Nativity of Vows

The vows taken by the members of the Night's Watch are solemn promises to serve and protect the realm. These vows are often summarized with the statement, 'I hold no lands, father no children.' This specific wording means that those who take these vows renounce any claims to lands or titles, and by extension, any rights to succession.

Reliance on Stark Support

The Night's Watch is in a unique position, as it relies heavily on the Starks of the North for support. This includes provision of food, equipment, and even prisoners captured in battle. The relationship between the Night's Watch and the Starks is not just transactional; it is built on trust and mutual benefit. In the event that Lord Ned Stark requested Jon's release, the Night's Watch would likely comply, given the strong relationship between the Starks and the Watch. However, this does not mean Jon would automatically be released from his vows without his own agreement.

Regulations on Release from Vows

The vows made by members of the Night's Watch are taken very seriously. The Night's Watch understands that such vows are too significant to be broken lightly. There have been rare instances in the series where members have been released from their duties, but these were under extreme and dire circumstances. Even King Robb Stark, during the War of the Five Kings, considered the possibility of releasing Jon from his vows for political gains. However, the precedent was not widely accepted, and there were no clear examples of widespread absolution of vows within the organizations.

Potential Scenarios

The release of Jon from his vows would depend on the specific circumstances. If Ned Stark appeared with undeniable proof of Jon's parentage and a clear case for Jon's claim to the Iron Throne, the Night's Watch might be more willing to consider releasing Jon. However, the decision would not be taken lightly. The Night's Watch would need to ensure that Jon's release would align with the best interests of the realm and the watch, not just personal ambitions.

Conclusion

The Night's Watch and its vows are deeply rooted in the traditions of Westeros. While Ned Stark's authority and the potential political implications of Jon Snow's claim could influence circumstances, the Night's Watch itself would require clear evidence and a compelling reason to release Jon from his vows. The likelihood of such an event is uncertain, but the complex nature of the vows and the close relationship between the Starks and the Night's Watch make Jon's potential release a topic of great interest and speculation within the series and among fans.